So you’ve been thinking about controlling your lights with your Google Home but your not sure where to start? We researched and tested the top home automation brands for light control and came up with the best solution for plug and play lighting automation.
You probably don’t know the details when it comes to home automation and you probably don’t want to spend thousands of dollars setting it up. Well, luckily for you, you don’t have to be a super rich rocket scientist to control your lights with your phone or with your voice. You also don’t have to buy weird bulky wall controllers and funny looking light bulbs. Keep reading to find out the brands we researched and tested, as well as the brand we ultimately purchased and installed in our home to control our lights with our Google Home.

Controlling our lights with the Google Home has been on my mind for some time and what better time to get it done than during our renovation. We were already replacing all of our light switches, outlets and cover plates so they matched. The previous homeowners must have been very eclectic as we found about 5 different colored switches, outlets and cover plates installed around the house. What goes on in the minds of our previous homeowners? The world may never know.

Now its time to actually purchase some smart lights. Time to research.
Philips Hue. I did look into Phillips Hue, but was not really wanting to buy light bulbs. I did not need my new calacatta marble counters to be adorned by color changing lights. I’m just not into it. You do have to purchase a $60 Philips Hue bridge to operate the lights and a lot of the times the lights don’t come with the bridge. Another thing to take into consideration with this is, if you have recessed LED lights or any light bulbs that cant be changed out (as we do have now in the kitchen), you will have one brand app for Philips Hue and another brand app for your switches to control those lights. You can sync all of your brands to your Google Home app, Smart Things, Amazon Alexa, etc. but to control the main settings or to configure more complicated settings, you will be utilizing the brands app. I do think the concept is pretty cool and looks to be super easy to install, I just like to minimize my apps and brands I work with. Of course it is impossible to have one app with everything, I just try to be conscious of it.
If there was a specific scenario where I had no other choice, like no switch, or if I was into setting up color changing moods, I would go with Philips Hue.
SmartThings. Samsung SmartThings seems to be pretty popular and widely used among many brands. With SmartThings you do have to buy a $70 hub, which isn’t really a huge deal. Philips Hue works with it, as well as GE Z-Wave smart switches to name a couple brands. And when I say GE Z-Wave has a switch for everything, I mean EVERYTHING. A huge plus was GE not only had switches for fan control, they had outdoor plugs!
I strongly considered going with SmartThings because of the seemingly endless amount of options that work with this brand. It all sounded too good to be true so I looked into it further. I pretended I purchased this system and went to install the app. Lets just say there was no shortage of bad reviews. As I read through the top reviews in the Google Play store, my hopes and dreams of Samsung SmartThings home automation were crashing and burning. I kept this option open, considering the possibility that most home automation reviews may be less than stellar, but this was a huge turn off. The last thing I need is another device I have to reset, reboot, uninstall, reinstall or ultimately throw into the lake out of frustration.
There is no doubt that Samsung SmartThings provides one of the best home automation solutions out there, but for my scenario of just needing light control, this wasn’t looking like the best option.
Leviton Decora Smart. Leviton makes switches and outlets but they are definitely not pioneers in home automation. The Leviton Decora Smart switches claim to work over Wifi and claim to not need a hub to operate. This brand was probably the easiest sounding scenario to go with. Just install the switch, connect the switch to the app over WiFi, connect the app to Google Home and BAM! You have a smart switch! The Leviton app had horrible reviews, even worse than SmartThings. But, the price was low and the seemingly easy set up was a plus. In comparison to the Lutron Casseta switches, they cost less and claim to offer the same functionality, without purchasing a hub.
So, I went for it. I bought a couple Leviton Decora Smart dimmer switches on Amazon to install in the kitchen. The package finally arrived and my husband began to install the first switch in the breakfast nook. He finished the installation and I began to try and connect the light to the Leviton app. Our excitement quickly turned into W T F. It was not going well. The instructions were followed exactly and I just could not get passed a certain point on the app. I searched the web. Nothing. I read forums. No solution. As much as I knew there had to be a solution, maybe if I called (please no), this was already enough for me to say, NO THANKS. This was supposed to be easy, plug and play lighting automation.
The next morning I had a stroke of genius and thought, let me try this on my old Samsung Galaxy Note 4 and see what happens. I just had a feeling. I dug up my old phone, turned it on and installed the Leviton app. Went through the same process as the day prior. Lo and behold, it works. The app connects and I can control the light. As impressed as I was with myself, considering my husband is an engineer and he couldn’t figure it out, I was still not so impressed with the scenario. It appeared to be an OS issue with the latest Android update. Who wants to wait for Leviton to catch up and provide us with an update so we can use their product. I also noticed that when controlling the light with Google Home, the light would not dim to it’s lowest setting which was also irritating. Livable but irritating.
Ultimately, and unfortunately, we were less than impressed with the Leviton Decora Smart switches. I foresaw a future of connectivity and functionality issues and returned the product.
Sorry Leviton! We have the regular Decora rocker switches and love them!

Lutron Caseta. After deciding to return the Leviton Decora Smart switches, I took a trip to Home Depot to purchase the Lutron Caseta switch to test this brand out. As I was shopping for switches Lutron was always in the back of my mind. I didn’t purchase this brand at first because the cost was greater and if Leviton worked, why pay more? Lutron Caseta Wireless switches do require an $80 smart bridge to operate and each switch costs about $10 or so more than the Leviton Decora Smart switches. Having to purchase and connect your automated lights to a bridge may not necessarily be a con. The bridge will provide seamless connectivity, whereas a product that connects directly to WiFi will more frequently experience connectivity issues.
My husband completed the installation of the Lutron Caseta switch and now, the moment of truth. I plugged the Lutron Caseta bridge into our modem, installed the app and began setting up the light. And what do you know, it WORKED. I then synced the Lutron app with Google Home and it connected seamlessly. This is exactly what I was looking for. Seamless plug and play integration with Google Home. Zero headaches. The extra expense for the Lutron Caseta smart switches have been more than worth it. We’ve been using these switches for a few months now with zero issues. We love them and are happy with our decision.
To sum it up, if you are looking for a simple solution to control your lights with Google Home, Lutron Caseta Wireless switches will not disappoint you.
The app is easy to use and provides great tools to control your lighting from scenes to schedules, the smart switches connect seamlessly to the Lutron app upon set-up and the Lutron app works perfectly with Google Home.

Thank you for reading! I welcome any questions, comments and suggestions. Please post them below!
Don’t forget to SUBSCRIBE by clicking SIGN-UP on the right or bottom of this page to have our latest DIY and design inspiration delivered straight to your inbox!
Follow us!































































































